|
[+]
1
|
2022-05-06 |
COMPLAINT filed by Christian Dior Couture, S.A.; Filing fee $ 402, receipt number AILNDC-19438503. |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
Exhibit 2 |
|
|
Exhibit 3 |
|
|
Exhibit 4 |
|
|
(Exhibit 5) |
|
2
|
2022-05-06 |
SEALED EXHIBIT by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. Schedule A regarding complaint 1 |
|
3
|
2022-05-06 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for leave to file under seal |
|
4
|
2022-05-06 |
CIVIL Cover Sheet |
|
5
|
2022-05-06 |
NOTIFICATION of Affiliates pursuant to Local Rule 3.2 by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. |
|
6
|
2022-05-06 |
Notice of Claims Involving Trademarks by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. |
|
7
|
2022-05-06 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Justin R. Gaudio |
|
8
|
2022-05-06 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Amy Crout Ziegler |
|
9
|
2022-05-06 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Allyson M. Martin |
|
[+]
10
|
2022-05-06 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Kasey Leigh Ewald |
|
|
CASE ASSIGNED to the Honorable Gary Feinerman. Designated as Magistrate Judge the Honorable Jeffrey Cummings. Case assignment: Random assignment. |
|
|
CLERK'S NOTICE: Pursuant to Local Rule 73.1(b), a United States Magistrate Judge of this court is available to conduct all proceedings in this civil action. If all parties consent to have the currently assigned United States Magistrate Judge conduct all proceedings in this case, including trial, the entry of final judgment, and all post-trial proceedings, all parties must sign their names on the attached Consent To form. This consent form is eligible for filing only if executed by all parties. The parties can also express their consent to jurisdiction by a magistrate judge in any joint filing, including the Joint Initial Status Report or proposed Case Management Order. |
|
11
|
2022-05-09 |
MAILED Trademark report to Patent Trademark Office, Alexandria VA |
|
12
|
2022-05-09 |
MAILED to plaintiff(s) counsel Lanham Mediation Program materials |
|
13
|
2022-05-10 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for temporary restraining order including a Temporary Injunction, a Temporary Transfer of the Defendant Domain Names, a Temporary Asset Restraint, and Expedited Discovery |
|
14
|
2022-05-10 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of motion for temporary restraining order[13] |
|
[+]
15
|
2022-05-10 |
DECLARATION of Justin R. Gaudio regarding memorandum in support of motion[14] |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
Exhibit 2 |
|
|
Exhibit 3 |
|
|
Exhibit 4 |
|
[+]
16
|
2022-05-10 |
DECLARATION of Nicolas Lambert regarding memorandum in support of motion[14] |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
Exhibit 2 |
|
|
Exhibit 3 |
|
|
Exhibit 4 |
|
17
|
2022-05-10 |
SEALED EXHIBIT by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. Exhibit 5 - Parts 1 - 9 regarding declaration[16] |
|
18
|
2022-05-10 |
SEALED EXHIBIT by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. Exhibit 6 regarding declaration[16] |
|
19
|
2022-05-10 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A.for Electronic Service of Process Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(f)(3) |
|
20
|
2022-05-10 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of motion for miscellaneous relief[19] |
|
[+]
21
|
2022-05-10 |
DECLARATION of Justin R. Gaudio regarding memorandum in support of motion[20] |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
Exhibit 2 |
|
|
Exhibit 3 |
|
22
|
2022-05-11 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Motions 3, 13, and 19 are entered and continued to 5/17/2022 at 9:00 a.m. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court. Mailed notice. |
|
23
|
2022-05-17 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Motion hearing held. Status hearing set for 5/31/2022 at 9:00 a.m. Plaintiff's motion for leave to file under seal [3], ex parte motion for entry of a temporary restraining order, including a temporary injunction, temporary transfer of the domain names, temporary asset restraint, and expedited discovery [13], and motion for electronic service of process [19] are granted. Enter sealed TRO. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 5/31/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
[+]
24
|
2022-05-17 |
SEALED TRO Signed by the Honorable Gary Feinerman on 5/17/2022.Mailed notice. |
|
|
SUMMONS Issued as to Defendant The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A |
|
25
|
2022-05-25 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for extension of time of Temporary Restraining Order as to Certain Defendants |
|
[+]
26
|
2022-05-25 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of extension of time 25 |
|
|
(Declaration of Allyson M. Martin) |
|
[+]
27
|
2022-05-25 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for preliminary injunction as to Certain Defendants |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
(Exhibit 2) |
|
[+]
28
|
2022-05-25 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of motion for preliminary injunction 27 |
|
|
Declaration of Allyson M. Martin |
|
|
(Exhibit 1) |
|
29
|
2022-05-25 |
SURETY BOND in the amount of $ 10,000 posted by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. (Document not scanned) |
|
[+]
30
|
2022-05-25 |
SUMMONS Returned Executed by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A on 5/25/2022, answer due 6/15/2022. |
|
|
Declaration of Kasey L. Ewald |
|
|
(Exhibit A) |
|
31
|
2022-05-31 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Rachel S Miller |
|
32
|
2022-05-31 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Status hearing held and continued to 7/12/2022 at 9:00 a.m. For the reasons stated on the record, Plaintiff's ex parte motion to extend the TRO 25 is denied as moot, and Plaintiff's motion for entry of a preliminary injunction as to certain defendants 27 is granted. Enter preliminary injunction order. The Clerk shall unseal any documents that are sealed. The Law Firm of Greer, Burns & Crain, Ltd., is ordered to add ALL defendant names listed in the Schedule A to the docket within three business days, instructions can be found on the Court's website at www.ilnd.uscourts.gov/instructions. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 7/12/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
[+]
33
|
2022-05-31 |
Preliminary injunction order Signed by the Honorable Gary Feinerman on 5/31/2022.Mailed notice. |
|
|
NEW PARTIES: didou, JHVYF, weigeer, BJSCSGD, ARTPETUR, xinyecheng, xiangchengshijiuqiaoshangmaoyouxiangongsi, Foleo Khaleesi, bashafashion, Zj's DD, Perfect-us, Hayybes, YunZ store, songqianqian, MITITEE JEWELRY, Agglutination store, GAOPENGJINGPING, FANGSHANGUNIANG, Blueyblue, WWearring, Luchttune, shangjiafang, MLJB Jewelry, zhangchenggui, Hua Sheg, Luxury bags for fashion, 19865244515p, amazingluxury0, avend.alan1758m51, ch.inaluxury, chaoalexliao, chbella2020, chen.fute, china.shoppingg, china_supp1ier1996, china_supplier3, chinaseller312, chinasuppliers_shoes_bag, chinese_luxury_suppliers, chinese_suppliers_no.1, chinese3106, cjcq7clq, emily.gzmimore, huizike, kai168007, lc5368361xingluo9, lihong992, lisa.luxbrand, luxury.seller.z, luxury_factory8, tangcao008, Grovision, Mundoaccesorios, amelinwuan88, francissalom85, DeJeans Shop Store, Comercial Bear Fashion, InGifts, Detailsdone, Vehiculistas, 9 To 5 Fashion Outlet, hambrazon, Irishon, Elbuhonero, liuhongyu2134, liuying2134, Facol Teusaquillo, ouyanghaozhou0947, liujiahan8763, Selsira, zhangrenli1187, Barquileta cafe, Desteyasta, lijiale3890, Cherristar, Chickenmar, warmrivers, VIYEC BUY, Flip flops mixer, Hostentozom, MapeMP, Tiendas daku2021, Treploxing, Glyderr, WilcomeG, OfficeHigh, kingscanyonnati33, kinlon diesel engine parts, Glory Fashion Its Shop, Nicollet, Avicola mi rebao, honeycasedi, FABIANNE, craft mugs, The Carry blue, Blackasia, diaquenca, Falt50, Quincalleria de Aquiles, Cirtil, Jeanp, Nasa Fashion, My Little Matilda, Mercosto, PSS World Medical, Mimidas, Controlod, Bucci For Big & Tall, Electric Store The Piquitos, gdajewelry.com, lightningshopping.com, brandsft.com, dioroutletsale.com, cheapdioroutlet.com, diorbagsonline.com and eevshop.com added to case caption. |
|
[+]
34
|
2022-06-09 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for preliminary injunction as to Certain Defendants |
|
|
Exhibit 1 |
|
|
(Exhibit 2) |
|
[+]
35
|
2022-06-09 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of motion for preliminary injunction 34 |
|
|
Declaration of Allyson M. Martin |
|
|
(Exhibit 1) |
|
[+]
36
|
2022-06-09 |
NOTICE of Motion by Allyson M. Martin for presentment of motion for preliminary injunction 34 before Honorable Robert M. Dow Jr. on 6/14/2022 at 09:15 AM. |
|
|
(Exhibit A) |
|
[+]
37
|
2022-06-09 |
SUMMONS Returned Executed by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A on 6/9/2022, answer due 6/30/2022. |
|
|
Declaration of Kasey L. Ewald |
|
|
(Exhibit A) |
|
38
|
2022-06-13 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Robert M. Dow, Jr: Motion by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for preliminary injunction as to Certain Defendants [34] will be heard telephonically before Judge Dow as Emergency Judge on 6/14/2022 at 9:15 a.m. Participants should use the Court's toll-free, call-in number 877-336-1829, passcode is 6963747. Emailed notice |
|
39
|
2022-06-13 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Thomas Joseph Juettner |
|
[+]
40
|
2022-06-14 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Robert M. Dow, Jr: This matter is before Judge Dow as Emergency Judge. Plaintiffs' motion for preliminary injunction as to Certain Defendants 34 is granted. A further status hearing is set for 8/1/2022 at 9:00 a.m. before Judge Feinerman. Emailed notice |
|
|
NEW PARTIES: Laura's quality clothes Store, FFCC Store, AWSL 55 Store, Anna Quality Clothes Store, Trend Base Store, IC Glass Store, 3737 Store, Jia yuan Factory Outlet Store, DYZ Store, JJGG99Bags Store, Bag Funland Store, chenzeng Store, Zeersic Store, PTX Shoe Store, mingjaa Store, LI YU FS 2 Store, CUPNICE Women Shopping Store, New surprise Store, PJ199202188L Store, YIQIFASHION Store, DHOOC Store, OKKDEY Store, Hi 1095 Men'sStore Store, SHOP018702283 Store, Aming02 Store, wqr aredg Store, facai224510bag Store, ppp8888888 Store, FXHRSYH Store, cchange bbettter Store, huangdada Store, lxj1997 Store, THENORTHF02 Store, JUNCAIXING03 Store, JUNCAIXING04 Store, DIXSG glasses Store, SZBYD92 Store, Yiwuhanfei888 Store, Nanjing Trading Store, YTBW08081 Store, fakeboy Store, Shop912624147 Store, Caijin Store, Shop912626036 Store, Presents From The Orient Store, asda-8 Store, GIOIO 01 Store, Z CINESSD Store, shop77799988 Store, HKDFY Store, Topsalelife98 Store, SuperAOnlineCC Store, HAOREN2021218 Store, Loving--Bags Store, Sexyworld Store, ADIESSS Store, hupinAccessories Store, The eu's Store, ZIJIAXUAN Store, European Menswear Store, Little sister 2 Store, S26 Store, SZAM01 Store, 360Degree Round Store, Kundy Store, GIOIO Official Store, transcendental Store, marksunshine0417 Store, luxury_handbags Store, lhy2o13 Store, petdogddy Store, godskr Store, ceessd Store, dreambuilder Store, designer_1_handbag Store, best0716 Store, pengsisi Store, keshbi Store, swimwear668 Store, boutiquebags8 Store, upline Store, finder66 Store, dh_sneakers Store, junlilac Store, designer_handbags_01 Store, mic_sneakers Store, Bean sprout flagship mall Store, Lady's Classic Bags Store, leotop168 Store, sunlei1992 Store, happygirl1314 Store, OFF FOR ALL Store, DH topclothing Store, phonecase_11 Store, chx825 Store, niceclothes88 Store, sup_001 Store, zuo8888 Store, liuzhenyu5200 Store and sup_bag Store added to case caption. |
|
[+]
41
|
2022-06-14 |
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDER AS TO CERTAIN DEFENDANTS Signed by the Honorable Gary Feinerman on June 14, 2022. Mailed notice |
|
|
NEW PARTIES: Laura's quality clothes Store, FFCC Store, AWSL 55 Store, Anna Quality Clothes Store, Trend Base Store, IC Glass Store, 3737 Store, Jia yuan Factory Outlet Store, DYZ Store, JJGG99Bags Store, Bag Funland Store, chenzeng Store, Zeersic Store, PTX Shoe Store, mingjaa Store, LI YU FS 2 Store, CUPNICE Women Shopping Store, New surprise Store, PJ199202188L Store, YIQIFASHION Store, DHOOC Store, OKKDEY Store, Hi 1095 Men'sStore Store, SHOP018702283 Store, Aming02 Store, wqr aredg Store, facai224510bag Store, ppp8888888 Store, FXHRSYH Store, cchange bbettter Store, huangdada Store, lxj1997 Store, THENORTHF02 Store, JUNCAIXING03 Store, JUNCAIXING04 Store, DIXSG glasses Store, SZBYD92 Store, Yiwuhanfei888 Store, Nanjing Trading Store, YTBW08081 Store, fakeboy Store, Shop912624147 Store, Caijin Store, Shop912626036 Store, Presents From The Orient Store, asda-8 Store, GIOIO 01 Store, Z CINESSD Store, shop77799988 Store, HKDFY Store, Topsalelife98 Store, SuperAOnlineCC Store, HAOREN2021218 Store, Loving--Bags Store, Sexyworld Store, ADIESSS Store, hupinAccessories Store, The eu's Store, ZIJIAXUAN Store, European Menswear Store, Little sister 2 Store, S26 Store, SZAM01 Store, 360Degree Round Store, Kundy Store, GIOIO Official Store, transcendental Store, marksunshine0417 Store, luxury_handbags Store, lhy2o13 Store, petdogddy Store, godskr Store, ceessd Store, dreambuilder Store, designer_1_handbag Store, best0716 Store, pengsisi Store, keshbi Store, swimwear668 Store, boutiquebags8 Store, upline Store, finder66 Store, dh_sneakers Store, junlilac Store, designer_handbags_01 Store, mic_sneakers Store, Bean sprout flagship mall Store, Lady's Classic Bags Store, leotop168 Store, sunlei1992 Store, happygirl1314 Store, OFF FOR ALL Store, DH topclothing Store, phonecase_11 Store, chx825 Store, niceclothes88 Store, sup_001 Store, zuo8888 Store, liuzhenyu5200 Store and sup_bag Store added to case caption. |
|
42
|
2022-06-27 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendants |
|
43
|
2022-06-30 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:The status hearing set for 7/12/2022 32 is stricken and re-set for 7/11/2022 at 9:00 a.m. The status hearing set for 8/1/2022 40 is stricken. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 7/11/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
44
|
2022-07-08 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendant |
|
45
|
2022-07-10 |
ATTORNEY Appearance for Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. by Kahlia Roe Halpern |
|
46
|
2022-07-11 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Status hearing held and continued to 8/17/2022 at 9:00 a.m. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 8/17/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
47
|
2022-07-15 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendants |
|
48
|
2022-07-29 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to Certain Defendants |
|
[+]
49
|
2022-07-29 |
MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for entry of default as to all Defendants, MOTION by Plaintiff Christian Dior Couture, S.A. for default judgment as to all Defendants |
|
|
(Exhibit A) |
|
[+]
50
|
2022-07-29 |
MEMORANDUM by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. in support of motion for entry of default, motion for default judgment 49 |
|
|
(Exhibit 1) |
|
[+]
51
|
2022-07-29 |
DECLARATION of Justin R. Gaudio regarding memorandum in support of motion 50 |
|
|
(Exhibit 1) |
|
52
|
2022-08-02 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Motion for entry of default and for default judgment 49 is entered and continued to 8/17/2022 at 9:00 a.m. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 8/17/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
53
|
2022-08-05 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendants |
|
54
|
2022-08-12 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendants |
|
55
|
2022-08-17 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Status hearing held and continued to 9/6/2022 at 9:00 a.m. For the reasons stated on the record, Plaintiff's renewed motion for entry of default and default judgment [49] is granted in part (as to the Rule 55(a) entry of default) and entered and continued in part (as to the Rule 55(b) default judgment). Enter Rule 55(a) default as to certain defendants. If any defendant wishes to oppose Plaintiff's Rule 55(b) motion for default judgment, that defendant should file a written opposition by 9/2/2022 or appear at the 9/6/2022 hearing; otherwise, the court will rule on the Rule 55(b) motion on the papers at the 9/6/2022 hearing. Attorneys/Parties should appear for the 9/6/2022 hearing by calling the Toll-Free Number: (877) 336-1828, Access Code: 4082461. Members of the public and media will be able to call in to listen to this hearing (use toll free number). Please, please be sure to keep your phone on mute when you are not speaking. Persons granted remote access to proceedings are reminded of the general prohibition against photographing, recording, and rebroadcasting of court proceedings. Violation of these prohibitions may result in sanctions, including removal of court issued media credentials, restricted entry to future hearings, denial of entry to future hearings, or any other sanctions deemed necessary by the Court.Mailed notice. |
|
56
|
2022-08-19 |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal by Christian Dior Couture, S.A. as to certain defendant |
|
57
|
2022-09-06 |
MINUTE entry before the Honorable Gary Feinerman:Status hearing held. For the reasons stated on the record, Plaintiff's motion for entry of default and default judgment [49] is granted in part. Enter order. Enter judgment order. Civil case closed.Mailed notice. |
|
58
|
2022-09-06 |
ENTERED JUDGMENT Signed by the Honorable Gary Feinerman on 9/6/2022.Mailed notice. |
|
59
|
2022-09-06 |
ENTERED JUDGMENT on 9/6/2022.Mailed notice. |
|
60
|
2022-09-09 |
FULL SATISFACTION of Judgment regarding entered judgment 58 in the amount of $200,000 as to certain defendant |
|
61
|
2022-09-16 |
FULL SATISFACTION of Judgment regarding entered judgment 58 in the amount of $200,000 as to certain defendant |
|
62
|
2022-09-30 |
FULL SATISFACTION of Judgment regarding entered judgment 58 in the amount of $200,000 as to certain defendants |
|
63
|
2023-03-02 |
FULL SATISFACTION of Judgment regarding entered judgment[58] in the amount of $200,000 as to certain defendant |
|
64
|
2023-08-31 |
FULL SATISFACTION of Judgment regarding entered judgment[58] in the amount of $200,000 as to certain defendant |
